Indeed, zionism is not strictly american race science and yet they are committing genocide and ethnic cleansing. However I doubt the USSR internally deported the germans because they were racist Russian supremacists. It’s a fundamentally incorrect comparison to make to a white supremacist ethnonationalist atrocity.
However I doubt the USSR internally deported the germans because they were racist Russian supremacists
They don’t need to be doing it for “Russian supremacy” for it to still “not be good” like you go off on american caliper based race science when the motivation for shuffling Germans around the USSR internally was the same as the motivation for japanese internment, that being that they “couldn’t be trusted” to not support their “homeland” against the USSR. It’s literally the same fucking thing.
They don’t need to be doing it for “Russian supremacy” for it to still “not be good”
Just to be clear, it “not being good” is an entirely different conversation to it “being the same as the japanese internment camps”.
On the point of these two events being “literally the same fucking thing”.
The amerisharts basically put all of their ethnically Japanese citizens in fucking concentration camps where they faced grave mistreatment, based on racist, bullshit ideas that still persist to this day about whites being superior and yellow skinned folk being fundamentally untrustworthy. The key here is an idea of the japanese not being just different but inferior to whites based on their skin color and ethnic background. This was a blatant hate crime motivated by ethnonationalist and racial supremacy.
This is a fundamentally different justification to the one you claim the USSR has. Being “different” is not the same as being “racially inferior”, and fears about them being loyal to their homeland were more understandable because their supposed ethnic homeland just launched a war of genocide against eastern European slavs, like the Russians in the USSR on the basis that ethnically german people are racially superior to slavs and thus are entitled to kill them and steal their land. It wasn’t “oh they are german so they are fundamentally untrustworhy because they are racially inferior subhumans”, it was “they are german so they are untrustworthy because germany just launched a genocidal war against us based on ethnic german supremacy”. A completely different situation to an inter-imperialist conflict between japan and america.
There is no such thing as “anti white/german racism” while white supremacist racism against nonwhite people is still being used as an excuse for genocide to this very second.
The most enlightening thing would be to get historical documents showing the USSRs actual motivations on paper.
you don’t have to be hopped up on american race science to do a genocide or ethnic cleansing
Indeed, zionism is not strictly american race science and yet they are committing genocide and ethnic cleansing. However I doubt the USSR internally deported the germans because they were racist Russian supremacists. It’s a fundamentally incorrect comparison to make to a white supremacist ethnonationalist atrocity.
They don’t need to be doing it for “Russian supremacy” for it to still “not be good” like you go off on american caliper based race science when the motivation for shuffling Germans around the USSR internally was the same as the motivation for japanese internment, that being that they “couldn’t be trusted” to not support their “homeland” against the USSR. It’s literally the same fucking thing.
Just to be clear, it “not being good” is an entirely different conversation to it “being the same as the japanese internment camps”.
On the point of these two events being “literally the same fucking thing”.
The amerisharts basically put all of their ethnically Japanese citizens in fucking concentration camps where they faced grave mistreatment, based on racist, bullshit ideas that still persist to this day about whites being superior and yellow skinned folk being fundamentally untrustworthy. The key here is an idea of the japanese not being just different but inferior to whites based on their skin color and ethnic background. This was a blatant hate crime motivated by ethnonationalist and racial supremacy.
This is a fundamentally different justification to the one you claim the USSR has. Being “different” is not the same as being “racially inferior”, and fears about them being loyal to their homeland were more understandable because their supposed ethnic homeland just launched a war of genocide against eastern European slavs, like the Russians in the USSR on the basis that ethnically german people are racially superior to slavs and thus are entitled to kill them and steal their land. It wasn’t “oh they are german so they are fundamentally untrustworhy because they are racially inferior subhumans”, it was “they are german so they are untrustworthy because germany just launched a genocidal war against us based on ethnic german supremacy”. A completely different situation to an inter-imperialist conflict between japan and america.
There is no such thing as “anti white/german racism” while white supremacist racism against nonwhite people is still being used as an excuse for genocide to this very second.
The most enlightening thing would be to get historical documents showing the USSRs actual motivations on paper.