• MizuTama [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 month ago

    its against tos lol. adblocking is also against YouTube TOS.

    I agree with the other points but they are insanely invasive in general. Wanting them to do it of their own volition without being strong-armed is the equivalent of a wish, so I think work with what we have. What we have is not good, but it is also better than not deleting things you want to, or having to manually do the several clicks per delete and the instead.

    Though I should’ve put a disclaimer its against TOS and do it only with that understanding and risks that may entail.

      • MizuTama [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        edit-2
        1 month ago

        not being able to do it in servers im not in is a bigger deal, and if you delete your account or get banned from discord the messages stay forever and you cant delete them at all. why are you defending them

        ??? Defending them?

        I’m saying they’re shit and you should expect shit to smell like shit and taste like shit.

        It is not me defending them but saying it is a pointless thing to discuss around theoretical what-ifs without some ability to change it. It would be nice if all messengers were EE2E, any data they did have on you they would delete on request, they gave their employees a fair wage (or wages were abolished because we are in a post-money society) with good benefits, didn’t further imperialism, and other wonderful things. Sadly, we live in hell, Discord is a massively intrusive messaging platform that doesn’t even pretend to encrypt their text messages with the encryption key on the servers like the “kind” porkies do, and—as the article above shows—it is part of the imperial intelligence apparatus.

        If you have a method or idea to make them implement this, I think that is a worthwhile thing to discuss. But I don’t and thus advocate for the tools that are there that I am aware of. Yes, it violates TOS. But I have yet to see a case of them properly enforce that particular violation, and the few times I’ve seen someone claim theirs was an example they had done something else that was a much more noticeable and problematic violation that was more likely the cause of the punishment. That could be a blind spot in my awareness. So again, if are concerned about TOS violations leading to lost accounts or other personal struggles from discord enforcing it (and it is a valid concern) I think it was a fair criticism that you levied for not mentioning it assuming that’s what you meant by bothering to mention it violates TOS. I’ll edit the post above to include it. But, since I think Discord is a piece of shit, I have no moral, ethical, spiritual, or other -al qualms with violating whatever terms, conditions, contracts, or stipulations they apply and only have concerns with the issues they may cause you for violating them if they decide to some day actually try to enforce those rules.

        Yes, you can’t delete from servers you’re not in. Yes, you can’t do it if your account is deleted or banned. Hence, me saying the current tools are not good. but as far as I know I presently, we don’t have the tools to force them to let us do those things. And I would like to be abundantly clear we would have to force Discord because it’s a piece of shit, and against its fundamental nature. If you have a method to circumvent it I would also be open to that, regardless of how how Discord would feel about it.

        But I was not defending them. They’re a corporation, they speak in money and power and will not give concessions via any other means.

          • MizuTama [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            1 month ago

            I mean I live in Amerikkka so GDPR didn’t cross my mind and I don’t know it’s intricacies enough for how that works. If you’re in a region it applies, maybe you can leverage a legal complaint of some kind? I know the few privacy laws we do have have a complaint system and I feel it’s fair to assume similar across the pond.

          • MizuTama [he/him, any]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            1 month ago

            I mean I live in Amerikkka so GDPR didn’t cross my mind and I don’t know it’s intricacies enough for how that works. If you’re in a region it applies, maybe you can leverage a legal complaint of some kind? I know the few privacy laws we do have have a complaint system and I feel it’s fair to assume similar across the pond.